China has told Bangladesh it will not fund coal mines and polluting power plants as Beijing takes the first tentative steps towards fulfilling its promises of sustainable Belt and Road investment.
In a letter seen by the Financial Times, China’s embassy to Bangladesh informed the local Ministry of Finance that “the Chinese side shall no longer consider projects with high pollution and high energy consumption, such as coal mining [and] coal-fired power stations”.
The letter, which was sent in February during negotiations over $3.6bn in infrastructure loans agreed in 2016 that Dhaka now wishes to repurpose, is a rare signal of Beijing’s hesitancy to fund polluting coal projects as part of the Belt and Road Initiative. The BRI is President Xi Jinping’s signature foreign policy drive to build China’s trade and infrastructure ties across dozens of countries.
It is “the first indication I’ve seen of [China’s promises of a green BRI] translating into action on the ground”, said Simon Nicholas, an Australia-based analyst for the Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis.
It remains unclear, however, whether the embassy’s letter was merely a reflection of conditions in Bangladesh or a broader move away from coal, he added.
Bangladesh government support for the energy sector has become a financial burden amid overcapacity of power plants and the rising cost of coal imports.
Nicholas noted that Beijing had yet to declare publicly an intent to curb overseas coal power development and failing to do so may be holding back the transition towards renewable energy in BRI countries that look to China for financing.
Vietnam was the largest recipient of overseas energy investment from Chinese companies in 2020. ICBC, the Chinese commercial bank, and state utility Southern Grid are in discussions to take over financing for the 2GW Vinh Tan 3 power plant after Mitsubishi Corp withdrew over climate change concerns, Vietnam’s state media reported in late February.
At home, China is also sending mixed signals about its readiness to reach peak carbon dioxide emissions. Xi failed to back up his surprise pledge that China would be “carbon neutral” by 2060 with the strong policy measures climate campaigners had hoped for in the country’s latest five-year economic blueprint released last week.
Environmentalists have identified BRI as central to determining whether developing countries can expand their economies cleanly and without undermining Paris Accord goals to keep global warming below 2 degrees compared with pre-industrial levels.
Without investment in renewable energy and other clean technologies, BRI countries could account for more than half of global carbon dioxide emissions by 2050 — up from about 26 per cent today, a 2019 study found.
China has repeatedly promised that BRI would be based on “pro green development”. A study backed by China’s Ministry of Ecology and Environment released in December called for a negative list of polluting projects to discourage environmentally harmful investments.
Last year, Chinese companies for the first time committed most of their energy investment to renewable projects.
Still, commercial deals may not align with that broader sustainability agenda so long as companies retain an appetite for coal investments, said Christoph Nedopil Wang, director of the Green BRI Center in Beijing.
“If this is to become a broader trend for Chinese overseas investments, ideally we would have a clear and stringent policy announcement from a high level of government — as high as possible,” he said.