Sports

Pele, Maradona, Messi, Ronaldo or Mbappe? There’s really no debate over The GOAT

As Kylian Mbappe completed his hat-trick against Barcelona on Tuesday, so the heir apparent platitudes began again.

Newspaper scribes and the Twitteratti alike rushed to claim that the handover of the world’s greatest player baton was nigh.

And even former Manchester United and England defender Rio Ferdinand joined in.

“I just feel he’s the guy now that’s going to take the throne, take the crown, he’s standing alone at the moment,” he said.

“It’s for everybody to catch up to him now.

“This guy is going to take over the throne from [Lionel] Messi and [Cristiano] Ronaldo when they’re done with it.”

Messi and his Barca team were well beaten by PSG

Ferdinand knows well what greatness looks like, having played alongside Ronaldo.

But he will also know there’s a marked difference between labelling someone a great and billing them as the greatest of an era given that, for the latter, there’ll never be an exact measure.

Someone who knows a thing or two about such debates is Pele and it’s something he discusses in the excellent new documentary bearing his name which is released on Netflix on Tuesday.

“I’ve never believed in the best player in the world,” he says. “To be the best player in the world you need to be better in every position than everyone else. And that’s tricky, isn’t it?”

A new Netflix documentary called Pele tells the story of the King’s World Cup heroics for Brazil

He’s right, of course, because as talented as Mbappe is, how can we say he’s a better footballer than Virgil van Dijk, Sergio Ramos, Jan Oblak and Manuel Neuer when they are all such different players with different jobs?

We haven’t yet seen whether or not Mbappe can cope with the physical and mental demands of playing in a serious league week in, week out, either, so can we really say he’ll be a better player than Kevin De Bruyne in the coming years?

Both are wonderful footballers but the greatest of the next decade? It’s impossible to say.

As for the debate about The GOAT — the greatest of all time — that’s even harder.

Legend Diego Maradona died aged 60 while football fan Jordan was in the I'm A Celebrity... Get Me Out Of Here castle
The late, great Diego Maradona will always be part of the great debate

Who knows if Pele and Diego Maradona’s bodies would have coped with the demands of modern-day football like Ronaldo and Messi have been able to?

And, likewise, who knows if Ronaldo or Messi would have achieved what those two achieved playing in a time when opponents weren’t just allowed to kick you but were encouraged to do so?

The political pressure Pele played under was astounding and we’ll never know if that trio or those numerous other great players could have dealt with it as he did.

Maybe, maybe not.

Such debates aren’t just limited to football.

Cristiano Ronaldo of Juventus
Opinion is split between Cristiano Ronaldo and Lionel Messi

Would Sachin Tendulkar or even Joe Root have had a better Test record than Sir Donald Bradman had they played at the same time?

Would Roger Federer would have won as many Grand Slams if he’d faced Bjorn Borg with a wooden racket, or would Franz Klammer have won as many downhill races if he’d been going head-to-head with Hermann Maier.

They are all pointless debates.

And instead of constantly wanting to proclaim different sportsmen and women as the greatest of all time, we’d be better off simply being grateful to all of them for the magic they’ve given us and will continue to give us.




Source link

Related Articles

Back to top button